Hollywood's "Fake" Mid-Atlantic Myth DEBUNKED!

Dr Geoff Lindsey June 30, 2024
Video Thumbnail
Dr Geoff Lindsey Logo

Dr Geoff Lindsey

@drgeofflindsey

About

Business Inquiries: [email protected] Hi! I want to share the fascination and fun of speech, language and accents, and I'm so grateful to anyone who feels able to support this work via my Patreon. I studied at University College London and got my PhD at the University of California Los Angeles. I've taught at universities including UCL, Edinburgh and Cambridge, published research in many areas, and worked as a forensic analyst. I've given invited lectures and workshops around the world. I wrote the influential 'English After RP' (Palgrave Macmillan), and my blog contains over a hundred audio-illustrated articles. I'm co-editor of the free searchable online pronouncing dictionary CUBE. I've also worked in film and TV as a screenwriter and director. I wrote the screenplay and arranged the music (performed by Lang Lang) for the animated fantasy Magic Piano, which was shortlisted for an Academy Award nomination.

Video Description

80,000 Hours is a nonprofit offering free research-based help on careers that make a difference. Get their in-depth guide at https://80000hours.org/drgeofflindsey. Want to know why actors in Golden Age Hollywood movies sound different from people today? A legend has grown up that it was all because an Australian and a Canadian invented a fake accent that studios forced their stars to use. Here I'll try to show why that's a load of you know what, and get closer to the fascinating reality. (Just to be clear: Wikipedia, which I support, is an invaluable resource on languages and linguistics, but this Wikipedia article cited a lot of sources by non-linguists.) 0:00 Introduction 3:21 Hollywood's beginnings 4:20 William Tilly 5:16 Problems with the 'fake' story 5:48 Rhoticity 6:58 Northeastern Elite 7:55 On stage and in public speaking 8:55 Edith Skinner 9:33 Katharine Hepburn 12:31 Intermission 14:33 Aspirational Hollywood 16:00 Cary Grant & Brits 16:44 Various other accents 20:16 Nasal nonsense 21:03 Kenyon & Knott's dictionary 22:18 Towards GenAm 23:50 The monster accent 24:17 Magnificence John McWhorter and Jessica Drake interviewed: https://www.mobituaries.com/news/death-of-an-accent John McWhorter on American non-rhoticity: https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=19486 Dudley Knight's article on Tilly & co: https://ktspeechwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Standard-Speech-The-Ongoing-Debate.pdf Hepburn interviews: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rqFzFyWnnhs and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfT_XWTldlo Drone footage of oil fields courtesy of Alexander X https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eaDDtimvUUQ Thank you to the Cinema Museum http://www.cinemamuseum.org.uk/ Los Angeles crew: Stewart Hoke and Steven Angelo

Classic Hollywood Essentials

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
2026 upgrade Brush Pro for Short Hair,brush pro canada short hair,brushes pro canada,portable straightenerbrush - brushpro,for Travel, with Led Display, for Short Hair, Medium Hair (#1)

2026 upgrade Brush Pro for Short Hair,brush pro canada short hair,brushes pro canada,portable straightenerbrush - brushpro,for Travel, with Led Display, for Short Hair, Medium Hair (#1)

(0)
$34.55
$5.54 delivery Jan 16 - Feb 5
Loading...
USB C Headphones for iPhone 17/16/16e/15 Pro Max/Plus, Type C Earbuds Wired Earphones (Microphone & Remote Control) Noise Cancelling for lPad Pro, Galaxy S23/S22/S21/S20

USB C Headphones for iPhone 17/16/16e/15 Pro Max/Plus, Type C Earbuds Wired Earphones (Microphone & Remote Control) Noise Cancelling for lPad Pro, Galaxy S23/S22/S21/S20

(30)
$12.59
FREE delivery Tue, Mar 24 on your first order
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
USB C Headphones for iPhone 17/16/16e/15 Pro Max/Plus, Type C Earbuds Wired Earphones (Microphone & Remote Control) Noise Cancelling for lPad Pro, Galaxy S23/S22/S21/S20/Ultra Note10/20, Pixel

USB C Headphones for iPhone 17/16/16e/15 Pro Max/Plus, Type C Earbuds Wired Earphones (Microphone & Remote Control) Noise Cancelling for lPad Pro, Galaxy S23/S22/S21/S20/Ultra Note10/20, Pixel

(23)
$12.59
FREE delivery Fri, Feb 13 on your first order
Loading...
Wireless Earbuds for Samsung S23 S24 S25 Ultra S21 S22 A35 A15 A14 iPhone 16 Pro 15 True Bluetooth 5.4 Headphones Ear Buds Noise Canceling in Ear Earphones,Deep Bass HiFi Stereo,Sweat Resistant,Mic

Wireless Earbuds for Samsung S23 S24 S25 Ultra S21 S22 A35 A15 A14 iPhone 16 Pro 15 True Bluetooth 5.4 Headphones Ear Buds Noise Canceling in Ear Earphones,Deep Bass HiFi Stereo,Sweat Resistant,Mic

(51)
$25.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
Apple AirPods Pro 2 Wireless Earbuds, Bluetooth Headphones, Active Noise Cancellation, Transparency, Personalized Spatial Audio, High-Fidelity Sound, H2 Chip, USB-C Charging

Apple AirPods Pro 2 Wireless Earbuds, Bluetooth Headphones, Active Noise Cancellation, Transparency, Personalized Spatial Audio, High-Fidelity Sound, H2 Chip, USB-C Charging

(26,678)
$259.99$194.99
FREE delivery Wed, Aug 20
5K+ bought in past month
Loading...
TONOR Dynamic Karaoke Microphone for Singing with 4.5m XLR Cable, Metal Handheld Mic Compatible with Karaoke Machine/Speaker/Amp/Mixer for Karaoke Singing, Speech, Wedding, Stage and Outdoor Activity
Best Seller

TONOR Dynamic Karaoke Microphone for Singing with 4.5m XLR Cable, Metal Handheld Mic Compatible with Karaoke Machine/Speaker/Amp/Mixer for Karaoke Singing, Speech, Wedding, Stage and Outdoor Activity

(14,437)
$19.97
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
400+ bought in past month
Loading...
SYRNARN 4 Pin XLR Balanced Headphone Cable Compatible with AUDEZE LCX-X LCD-XC LCD2 LCD3 LCD4 for MEZE Empyrean, MEZE Elite, MEZE Empyrean 16 Core Replacement Cord (4 Pin XLR Balanced, 2Meters/6.5ft)

SYRNARN 4 Pin XLR Balanced Headphone Cable Compatible with AUDEZE LCX-X LCD-XC LCD2 LCD3 LCD4 for MEZE Empyrean, MEZE Elite, MEZE Empyrean 16 Core Replacement Cord (4 Pin XLR Balanced, 2Meters/6.5ft)

(14)
$120.99
FREE delivery Sep 3 - 15
Loading...
SmallRig FX3 / FX30 HawkLock Quick Release Camera Cage Kit for Sony with XLR Handle Extension, Wrist Strap and Cable Clamp for HDMI, QR Cold Shoe, NATO Rail/QR Plate for Arca,Titanium Gray - 4771

SmallRig FX3 / FX30 HawkLock Quick Release Camera Cage Kit for Sony with XLR Handle Extension, Wrist Strap and Cable Clamp for HDMI, QR Cold Shoe, NATO Rail/QR Plate for Arca,Titanium Gray - 4771

(72)
$174.24$162.04
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19
Loading...
SmallRig FX3 / FX30 HawkLock Quick Release Camera Cage Kit for Sony with Cable Clamp, Bulit-in QR Cold Shoe NATO Rail/QR Plate for Arca, Modular Design Compatible with Original XLR Handle - 4770

SmallRig FX3 / FX30 HawkLock Quick Release Camera Cage Kit for Sony with Cable Clamp, Bulit-in QR Cold Shoe NATO Rail/QR Plate for Arca, Modular Design Compatible with Original XLR Handle - 4770

(35)
$124.94
FREE delivery Thu, Jun 19
Loading...
Lamicall Adjustable Phone Stand for Desk - 360 Rotating Foldable Cell Phone Holder Desktop Portable Cellphone Stand, Office Desk Accessories for iPhone 17 16 15 14 Pro Max, 4-10”Smartphones, iPad Mini Global Recycled Standard

Lamicall Adjustable Phone Stand for Desk - 360 Rotating Foldable Cell Phone Holder Desktop Portable Cellphone Stand, Office Desk Accessories for iPhone 17 16 15 14 Pro Max, 4-10”Smartphones, iPad Mini Global Recycled Standard

(1,781)
$13.99
FREE delivery Sat, Apr 11 on your first order
300+ bought in past month