Should You Pay Off Your Mortgage or Invest? (A 50-year historical backtest)

James Shack January 29, 2024
Video Thumbnail
James Shack Logo

James Shack

@jamesshack

About

A financial planner making videos about money, financial independence and living a good life. Disclaimer: All of my views are my own, and not representative of any company. Any personal opinions, ideas, and tips represented on this channel should not be seen as financial advice or a recommendation to take any specific course of action. James Shack™ property of James Shackell Copyright © James Shackell 2014. All rights reserved. The author asserts their moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identified as the author of this channel and any video published on it.

Video Description

A look into the past to assess how often investing has beaten paying off your mortgage. Graphs from the video https://go.novawm.com/MortgageGraphs Looking for help with Financial Planning? I am a Chartered Wealth Manager and Partner in a financial planning practice based in the UK. If you would like to find out more about working with us, please follow this link: https://go.novawm.com/yt/74 Capital at risk. Past performance is used as a guide only. It is no guarantee of future returns. Different funds and asset classes carry varying levels of risk depending on the geographical region and industry sector. You should make yourself aware of these specific risks prior to investing. Mortgage rates and eligibility are dependent on your personal circumstances. With interest only mortgages there is a chance that the repayment vehicle you have in place won't perform as well as you hoped, leaving you unable to afford the lump sum. In this case, you may need to sell your home or find another way to pay off the balance. Prevailing tax rates and reliefs are dependent on your individual circumstances and are subject to change. We do not provide tax advice. Any examples used in the video are for illustrative purposes only and you may get less back than the figures shown. This video does not constitute personal advice. We do not take any responsibility for third party websites and content we may link to from this video. Issued on behalf of Nova. Nova is a trading name of Nova Wealth Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN: 778951) and is a limited company registered in England & Wales (10739796). James Shack™ property of James Shackell Copyright © James Shackell 2024. All rights reserved. The author asserts their moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identified as the author of this channel and any video published on it. 00:00 The Problem with Averages 02:24 Tom & His Question 04:07 Historical Market Data 05:24 How the Test Works 07:13 ISA Results 09:24 Different Mortgage Sizes 09:47 Pension Results 12:28 Pension +1 13:34 Different Time Periods 14:27 60% Stocks 40% Bonds 16:31 Key Considerations 19:26 Why this was not for Tom

Upgrade Your iPhone Experience

AI-recommended products based on this video

Loading...
for Magsafe Car Mount【20 Strong Magnets 】Magnetic Phone Holder for Car Phone Holder Mount Dash【360°】Cell Phone Mount for Car Accessories,Car Mount for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Plus MagSafe Cases

for Magsafe Car Mount【20 Strong Magnets 】Magnetic Phone Holder for Car Phone Holder Mount Dash【360°】Cell Phone Mount for Car Accessories,Car Mount for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Plus MagSafe Cases

(11,563)
$16.98
FREE delivery Tue, Jun 17 on your first order
3K+ bought in past month
Loading...
Magnetic Wireless Charger for iPhone - 3 in 1 Mag-Safe Charging Station for Multiple Devices Apple - Charger Stand Dock for Apple Watch iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 Pro Max Plus Airpods

Magnetic Wireless Charger for iPhone - 3 in 1 Mag-Safe Charging Station for Multiple Devices Apple - Charger Stand Dock for Apple Watch iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 Pro Max Plus Airpods

(750)
$59.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
Loading...
4-in-1 Wireless Magnetic Power Bank 10800mAh Portable Charger with iWatch Charger, QC4.0+20W PD Fast Charging USB C Battery Pack for Magsafe, iPhone 16/15/14/13/12 Series, Apple Watch etc. (White)

4-in-1 Wireless Magnetic Power Bank 10800mAh Portable Charger with iWatch Charger, QC4.0+20W PD Fast Charging USB C Battery Pack for Magsafe, iPhone 16/15/14/13/12 Series, Apple Watch etc. (White)

(581)
$42.95
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
Loading...
eazpower for Magsafe Power Bank 10000mAh, Magnetic Battery Pack Wireless, 20W PD Fast Charging, Compact Portable Charger with Built-in Cables and Stand for iPhone 16/15/14/13/12/ Apple Watch/Airpods

eazpower for Magsafe Power Bank 10000mAh, Magnetic Battery Pack Wireless, 20W PD Fast Charging, Compact Portable Charger with Built-in Cables and Stand for iPhone 16/15/14/13/12/ Apple Watch/Airpods

(330)
$39.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
200+ bought in past month
Loading...
Anker 332 USB-C Hub (5-in-1) with 4K HDMI Display, 5Gbps - and 2 5Gbps USB-A Data Ports and for MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, Dell XPS, Lenovo Thinkpad, HP Laptops and More

Anker 332 USB-C Hub (5-in-1) with 4K HDMI Display, 5Gbps - and 2 5Gbps USB-A Data Ports and for MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, Dell XPS, Lenovo Thinkpad, HP Laptops and More

(11,639)
$23.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
Spigen Case for Galaxy S25 Case, Tough Armor (Ai) MagFit [Wireless Charging] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

Spigen Case for Galaxy S25 Case, Tough Armor (Ai) MagFit [Wireless Charging] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

(2,126)
$28.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Case, Tough Armor Designed for Apple iPhone 16 - Black

Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Case, Tough Armor Designed for Apple iPhone 16 - Black

(126)
$22.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Pro Case, Tough Armor [MagFit] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Pro Case, Tough Armor [MagFit] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

(341)
$32.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Plus Case, Tough Armor (AI) [MagFit] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

Spigen Case for iPhone 16 Plus Case, Tough Armor (AI) [MagFit] Compatible with MagSafe - Black

(818)
$29.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
VANMASS [85+LBS Strongest Suction & Clip] 2025 Upgrade Car Phone Holder [Patent & Safety Certs] Cell Phone Mount Truck Stand for Dashboard Windshield Vent for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Samsung

VANMASS [85+LBS Strongest Suction & Clip] 2025 Upgrade Car Phone Holder [Patent & Safety Certs] Cell Phone Mount Truck Stand for Dashboard Windshield Vent for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Samsung

(54,882)
$32.25
FREE delivery Mon, Aug 25 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

(4,036)
$8.99
FREE delivery Sun, Jun 29 on your first order
2K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

(5,626)
$17.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

(2,193)
$14.24
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
400+ bought in past month
Loading...
Apple AirPods Pro 2 Wireless Earbuds, Bluetooth Headphones, Active Noise Cancellation, Transparency, Personalized Spatial Audio, High-Fidelity Sound, H2 Chip, USB-C Charging

Apple AirPods Pro 2 Wireless Earbuds, Bluetooth Headphones, Active Noise Cancellation, Transparency, Personalized Spatial Audio, High-Fidelity Sound, H2 Chip, USB-C Charging

(26,678)
$259.99$194.99
FREE delivery Wed, Aug 20
5K+ bought in past month
Loading...
3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone, Wireless Charger for iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 11 X Pro Max & Apple Watch - Charging Stand Dock for AirPods Global Recycled Standard

3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone, Wireless Charger for iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 11 X Pro Max & Apple Watch - Charging Stand Dock for AirPods Global Recycled Standard

(30,415)
$30.39
Prime
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone, Wireless Charger for iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 11 X Pro Max & Apple Watch - Charging Stand Dock for AirPods (Blue) Global Recycled Standard

3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone, Wireless Charger for iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 11 X Pro Max & Apple Watch - Charging Stand Dock for AirPods (Blue) Global Recycled Standard

(27,328)
$39.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
Wireless Charger for iPhone- 3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone 16/15/14/13/12/Pro Max/Pro/Mini/Plus, Apple Watch 10/9/8/7/SE/6/5/4/3/2/1/Ultra2/Ultra, AirPods pro/2/3/4

Wireless Charger for iPhone- 3 in 1 Charging Station for iPhone 16/15/14/13/12/Pro Max/Pro/Mini/Plus, Apple Watch 10/9/8/7/SE/6/5/4/3/2/1/Ultra2/Ultra, AirPods pro/2/3/4

(27)
$27.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
Loading...
soundcore by Anker P20i True Wireless Earbuds, 10mm Drivers with Big Bass, Bluetooth 5.3, 30H Long Playtime, IPX5 Water-Resistant, 2 Mics for AI Clear Calls, 22 Preset EQs, Customization via App

soundcore by Anker P20i True Wireless Earbuds, 10mm Drivers with Big Bass, Bluetooth 5.3, 30H Long Playtime, IPX5 Water-Resistant, 2 Mics for AI Clear Calls, 22 Preset EQs, Customization via App

(61,759)
$29.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
4K+ bought in past month
Loading...
soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel

soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel

(39,496)
$52.99
FREE delivery Sun, Oct 19
3K+ bought in past month
Loading...
soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel

soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel

(30,156)
49.98
PrimeFREE delivery Saturday, June 14
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel
Amazon's Choice

soundcore by Anker Q20i Hybrid Active Noise Cancelling Headphones, Wireless Over-Ear Bluetooth, 40H Long ANC Playtime, Hi-Res Audio, Big Bass, Customize via an App, Transparency Mode, Ideal for Travel

(30,156)
49.97
PrimeFREE delivery Saturday, June 14
3K+ bought in past month
Loading...
VANMASS [85+LBS Strongest Suction & Clip] 2025 Upgrade Car Phone Holder [Patent & Safety Certs] Cell Phone Mount Truck Stand for Dashboard Windshield Vent for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Samsung

VANMASS [85+LBS Strongest Suction & Clip] 2025 Upgrade Car Phone Holder [Patent & Safety Certs] Cell Phone Mount Truck Stand for Dashboard Windshield Vent for iPhone 16 Pro Max 15 14 13 12 Samsung

(54,882)
$32.25
FREE delivery Mon, Aug 25 on your first order
1K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

(4,036)
$8.99
FREE delivery Sun, Jun 29 on your first order
2K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

(5,626)
$17.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

(2,193)
$14.24
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
400+ bought in past month
Loading...
Magnetic Wireless Charger for iPhone: Fodable 3 in 1 Charging Station for Multiple Apple Devices - Travel Charging Pad Dock for Apple Watch iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 Pro Max Plus & Airpod Global Recycled Standard

Magnetic Wireless Charger for iPhone: Fodable 3 in 1 Charging Station for Multiple Apple Devices - Travel Charging Pad Dock for Apple Watch iPhone 16 15 14 13 12 Pro Max Plus & Airpod Global Recycled Standard

(656)
$49.99
PrimeFREE delivery Sat, Jun 14
100+ bought in past month
Loading...
2 Pack Magnetic Wireless Charger 15W Fast Mag-Safe Charger Stand Compatible with iPhone 16/15/14/13/12 Series Wireless Charging Pad for AirPods 3/2/Pro 2/Pro White Portable Mag Safe Kickstand

2 Pack Magnetic Wireless Charger 15W Fast Mag-Safe Charger Stand Compatible with iPhone 16/15/14/13/12 Series Wireless Charging Pad for AirPods 3/2/Pro 2/Pro White Portable Mag Safe Kickstand

(31)
$24.69
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
500+ bought in past month
Loading...
Wireless Earbuds, 2025 Bluetooth 5.4 Bass Stereo Headphones with 4 ENC Mic, 48H Playback Ear Buds with Charging Case LED Display,Sport Earphones IPX7 Waterproof for Phone, Android, Pad, White

Wireless Earbuds, 2025 Bluetooth 5.4 Bass Stereo Headphones with 4 ENC Mic, 48H Playback Ear Buds with Charging Case LED Display,Sport Earphones IPX7 Waterproof for Phone, Android, Pad, White

(38)
$27.99
Prime
Loading...
iPhone Charger Cord Lightning Cable (Apple MFi Certified) 6/6/10ft 3 Pack iPhone Cable Fast Charging Long Apple Charger Cable for iPhone 13 13 Pro 12 Pro 11 SE Max XS XR X, iPad Mini Air, iPod, AirPod

iPhone Charger Cord Lightning Cable (Apple MFi Certified) 6/6/10ft 3 Pack iPhone Cable Fast Charging Long Apple Charger Cable for iPhone 13 13 Pro 12 Pro 11 SE Max XS XR X, iPad Mini Air, iPod, AirPod

(4,371)
$9.99
FREE delivery Sat, Sep 20 on your first order
6K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

iPhone Charger Fast Charging [Apple MFi Certified] USB C to Lightning Cable 6FT USBC to Lightning Cable Nylon Braided Type C Cord for iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XR XS X 8 7 6 Plus SE, iPad

(4,036)
$8.99
FREE delivery Sun, Jun 29 on your first order
2K+ bought in past month
Loading...
iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

iPhone Charger [Apple MFi Certified] 3FT, 3Pack USB A to Lightning Cable Braided Fast Charging Apple Cord Compatible with iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad/iPod/AirPods

(5,626)
$17.99
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
50+ bought in past month
Loading...
2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

2Pack 10ft iPhone Charger 90 Degree Lightning Cable Right Angle Long USB Charging Cord Compatible with Apple iPhone 14 13 12 11 Pro Max XS XR X 8 7 6 5 Plus iPad iPod

(2,193)
$14.24
FREE delivery Sat, Jun 14 on your first order
400+ bought in past month
Loading...
Anker USB C Cable, [2-Pack, 6 ft] Type C Charger Premium Nylon USB Cable, USB A to Type C Charging Cable Fast Charge for Samsung Galaxy S10 S10+ / Note 8, LG V20 and Other USB C Charger (Black)

Anker USB C Cable, [2-Pack, 6 ft] Type C Charger Premium Nylon USB Cable, USB A to Type C Charging Cable Fast Charge for Samsung Galaxy S10 S10+ / Note 8, LG V20 and Other USB C Charger (Black)

(103,365)
$13.49
5K+ bought in past month